Expanding the Scope of Restorative Practices and Principles: Beyond Juvenile Justice
By Judge J. Wesley Saint Clair, Retired
Introduction
Restorative Practices and Principles (RPP) have long been associated with juvenile justice as a rehabilitative alternative to punitive measures. However, the potential of RPP extends well beyond youth-focused interventions. Limiting restorative approaches to juvenile justice underestimates their capacity to foster healing, accountability, and long-term transformation across various legal, educational, and community settings.
RPP can be particularly transformative in areas such as family law, probate matters, anti-harassment civil calendars, housing disputes, financial conflicts, workplace and human resources, policing, and even international conflict resolution. These applications underscore that RPP is not about being "soft on crime" or excusing harmful behavior; rather, it ensures meaningful accountability through structured dialogue and problem-solving.
Restorative approaches are relational rather than transactional, shifting the focus from merely assigning blame and punishment to addressing harm in a way that promotes resolution, healing, and long-term prevention. This article explores the broader applications of RPP, outlining how its principles can be leveraged in diverse contexts to enhance justice, social cohesion, and economic efficiency.
Restorative Practices and Principles: A Framework for Accountability and Healing
Restorative Practices and Principles prioritize repairing harm and restoring relationships instead of relying solely on punitive or adversarial measures. These practices involve structured dialogue that allows those harmed and those responsible for harm to engage in meaningful conversations, working toward mutual understanding and constructive resolutions.
What RPP Is Not
RPP Is Not Soft on Crime – A key tenet of RPP is accountability. It ensures that individuals who have caused harm must take ownership of their actions and actively work toward repairing the damage. Studies have shown that restorative approaches lead to higher rates of accountability and victim satisfaction than punitive measures (Daly, 2016).
RPP Is Not a Replacement for Legal Systems – Instead of being a substitute, RPP serves as a complementary tool that enhances legal processes by emphasizing relational justice over procedural technicalities.
RPP Is Not Just for Juveniles – While it has gained traction in juvenile justice, RPP has proven effective in adult legal cases, civil disputes, corporate settings, and community conflict resolution (Zehr, 2015).
RPP Is Not a Quick Fix – Rather than seeking immediate resolutions through punitive measures, RPP fosters long-term healing, relationship-building, and systemic change.
Expanding the Application of RPP
1. Schools and Child Welfare
The education system has increasingly adopted RPP to create safer and more inclusive learning environments. Schools that integrate restorative practices report reductions in disciplinary actions, improved student engagement, and healthier school climates (Gregory et al., 2016). Rather than relying on punitive measures such as suspensions and expulsions, restorative circles and peer mediation programs encourage students to address conflicts constructively.
Applications in Schools:
Restorative circles to address bullying and interpersonal conflicts.
Peer mediation programs to empower students to resolve disputes.
Reintegration circles for students returning from suspension to restore relationships.
In child welfare, RPP helps prevent unnecessary family separations and reduces trauma. Family group conferencing, in which extended family members collaborate on care plans, has been effective in ensuring children's well-being while addressing concerns (Burford & Hudson, 2000).
2. Courts and Sentencing Reform
Restorative justice programs within criminal courts have successfully reduced recidivism and increased victim satisfaction. Many courts now use restorative diversion programs that allow offenders to engage in structured dialogues with victims, complete community service, or agree to restitution arrangements (Latimer, Dowden, & Muise, 2005).
Applications in Courts:
Victim-offender dialogues to facilitate healing and accountability.
Restorative sentencing circles involving community members in decision-making.
Post-incarceration reintegration circles to support successful reentry into society.
Restorative courts ensure that justice is not merely punitive but also reparative and transformative.
3. Family Law and Probate Matters
Family disputes, especially divorce, child custody, and inheritance, are often adversarial. RPP offers a collaborative approach that encourages dialogue and mutual understanding, reducing hostility and legal costs (Walker & Hayashi, 2009).
Applications:
Restorative mediation for high-conflict divorce and custody disputes.
Family conferencing to prevent litigation over probate and inheritance issues.
Restorative elder care planning to address disputes involving guardianship.
These processes help families navigate complex emotional and financial disputes while preserving relationships.
4. Civil Anti-Harassment and Protection Order Calendars
Civil harassment disputes often escalate in adversarial court settings. RPP provides alternative dispute resolution methods that encourage de-escalation and mutual understanding (Karp & Frank, 2016).
Applications:
Workplace mediation to resolve harassment claims constructively.
Community-based restorative programs to reduce repeated conflicts.
Harm-reduction circles for neighbors and co-workers involved in disputes.
By shifting from litigation to dialogue, restorative practices reduce tension and promote healing.
5. Housing Disputes and Evictions
Housing instability is a pressing issue, and traditional eviction proceedings often exacerbate financial hardship. Restorative housing mediation provides solutions that allow landlords and tenants to find workable alternatives (Schiff, 2013).
Applications:
Landlord-tenant mediation to negotiate fair lease terms and repayment plans.
Community housing circles to prevent displacement due to gentrification.
Restorative processes in public housing to address tenant disputes.
These approaches help reduce homelessness and foster community stability.
6. Workplace and Human Resources Conflicts
Restorative justice is becoming a preferred method for conflict resolution in workplaces, improving employee relationships, reducing grievances, and fostering healthier work environments (Wachtel, 2016).
Applications in HR:
Restorative mediation for resolving interpersonal conflicts.
Repairing harm caused by workplace discrimination or harassment.
Restorative leadership training to create inclusive and accountable workplaces.
Organizations that embrace restorative HR models experience improved employee retention and job satisfaction.
7. Policing and Community Safety
Restorative policing models have been successfully implemented to reduce youth arrests and repair community relations. Law enforcement agencies using restorative dialogue approaches report fewer repeat offenses and improved community trust.
Applications in Policing:
Restorative dialogues between police and communities to rebuild trust.
Alternatives to traditional disciplinary actions for youth offenders.
Officer training in restorative conflict resolution strategies.
This model shifts law enforcement from a punitive approach to a community-centered model
Comments